13. July 2008

Red Cliff

After 8 months of eager anticipation and waiting, Red Cliff finally debuted on the big screen last Thursday. So like Friday went to catch the “EPIC” movie directed by John Woo and after 2 hours and 30 minutes of screen time, it’s utter disappointment for me.

There are so many letdowns on that movie. The casting seems weird, the screenplay seems crazy enough and there is XingBa, YunChang, Yide and Zilong all as mere tools for Zhou and Zhuge in killing.

There Zhang FengYi as Cao Cao which I felt that is extremely being miscast. He is a brilliant actor but still I couldn’t sense Cao’s deviousness and that Hero of Chaos aura coming out of the actor. In fact, I couldn’t even sense Guan Yu magnificent aura there as well. He is being reduced as a mere mortal perhaps to make it more real? His blade isn’t really fanciful as well compared to every source out there. The worst is Zhang Fei, which doesn’t even carry its trademark the Snake Headed Spear.

Of course there are cool fighting scenes for Guan Yu and the rescuing of Liu Chan by Zhao Yun but it isn’t much of that “Epic” either. The pivotal Zhu-ge and Zhou have been apocryphally depicted as rivals, but Woo's decision to follow history and turn them into potential soul mates weakens dramatic power. The movie also made Zhou Yu into a much better person compared to the novel which is petty and always doing small things to harm Zhuge.

What I can say is, the movie isn’t that bad nor is it that good. There is still cool strategic formation that is used in battles against Cao's 200,000 cavalry assault. The masterfully varied cinematography captures an astounding array of military pageantry, martial arts sequences and ancient weaponry that could be a part of that “EPIC” thing going on.

Bottom-line still goes its watch able but if you’re into Romance of the Three Kingdom, it will be a disappointing let down.


Comments
 
Name

Email

URL


Remember me?

Comments


Verification code
Verification code